Wiki Spaces

Documentation
Projects
Resources

Get Help from Others

Q&A: Ask OpenMRS »
Discussion: OpenMRS Talk »
Real-Time: IRC Chat

Resources

Skip to end of metadata
Go to start of metadata

This story grew out of years of watching Clem McDonald in action, famously productive, while others seemed to spin their wheels. It is much the same message as the Cathedral and the Bazaar.

Clem and another group are faced with the same challenge: build a bridge across a canyon. 

The other group — like most of us would — gathers engineers, draws up specifications, and begins planning on how the bridge should be constructed properly.  Meanwhile, Clem pulls a box of dental floss out of his pocket, unwinds it, and throws it across the canyon. Almost immediately, he's got something across the canyon. It's only floss, but it's there — end to end.

The other group is arguing about whether the bridge should be a beam, suspension, truss, or arch bridge.  Clem starts layering paper mâché onto the floss.

The other group has finally decided on a suspension bridge and begins preparing the materials according to specifications.  Clem has people walking across his paper mâché bridge.

The other group realizes that they would probably be better off with a truss bridge, begins discussions on the new specifications, and then realizes that they are too far over budget and the project is shut down.  Clem has people driving across his bridge.

The other group finally creates their version of the bridge, only to realize it doesn't reach over to the other side where they initially intended it to!

The Lesson

Whenever possible, start with the floss. See the solution through end-to-end, since this is often the best way to understand the problem and often informs the next pass at the solution. In the end, it is rare that we fully understand the problem until the third iteration of the solution.

Be agile, open to corrections, and iterate on your solutions. But, most importantly, take action.

  • No labels

4 Comments

  1. Love the story, But I don't think Clem was Agile

    1. Hmm, why don't you think so? Would like to hear your ideas about the story. (smile)

  2. I think Clem used the waterfall methodology, also watched the video(soooooo inspired, it was unbelievable when he started).............Personally too, I don't fully enjoy agile, especially for new Applications (where there is not yet a full full understanding of the final product) Agile is best for maintenance IMO.

    1. "gathers engineers, draws up specifications, and begins planning on how the bridge should be constructed properly"(This is Agile I am talking about, too much protocols)
    2. "Meanwhile, Clem pulls a box of dental floss out of his pocket, unwinds it, and throws it across the ................."(That's how I think a new software development Project should begin)

    Working on a  new App now where I currently work....................scared of late Sprints(eusoping time for my favourite openMRS(sad)..lol), this also does not make one add new ideas during development, You just want to meet your deadline. I prefer the waterfall Process for a new Application and Agile for feature addition of bug fix and so on.......

    1. John Alade,

      I'm afraid you have this backwards. The point of Clem's floss was to get something... anything... working end-to-end and then iterate on it. This iterative approach was much like the Agile methods that have since developed (i.e., create a minimum viable product and iterate on it, so the solution itself can contribute to learning requirements). It was the "other group" using the waterfall methodology, frozen by gathering requirements and designing for the perfect solution against whom Clem prevailed. One of the primary failings of the waterfall methodology is assuming that all design & requirements are necessary before work can begin and not responding "agilely" as new requirements and shortcomings of design are discovered during implementation and testing.

      Cheers,

      -Burke